This is for the fun meet competitions here in Michigan. When my daughter was a level 2, they would do the level 2-floor, beam & bar routine, but level 3 vault.
Ask yourself...would YOU do this to your daughter? If the answer is no, then why would you be ok with someone else doing this to her.
I understand being an overprotective mom. Which IMO there's no such thing in this day and age. You need to protect your child as much as possible. Not allowing...
She can perform the skills with no issues. Her issue is form. Bent legs, toes not pointed, not fluent, etc. Of course with that, those issues equal lots of deductions.
At my DD gym we have a gymnast that pretty similar to what you've described. I questioned this to one of the parents on her team and was told that the gymnast works hard, highly motivated, compassionate and love the sport. I took that answer to be perfect for her situation.
Pretty sure this is true. The last gym my dd was at the owner had all the coaches sign a contract upon hire. In that contract, it had a clause in it that stated if they quit they can not coach or open their own gym within a 30 mile radius for 1 year. 2 coaches quit. 1 opened their own gym...
Can you send me a PM of the other gyms you are referring to? I'm also in this same state, considering switching clubs. I don't want to make the wrong decision.
thank you