Just Dance 2016 for Wii/Xbox
Alex & Ani bracelet or jewelry from Claire's
Monogrammed bathrobe or swimsuit coverup
Big slippers or fuzzy socks
Certificate for mani/pedi
Minecraft anything - legos, books
Flavored lip gloss in fun flavors
Cute purse with tiny lotion, lip balm, emory board, kid-friendly mirror, note pad/pen
My girls are older (12 & nearly 14), but they always liked these types of things.